The Madness of Brad Childress

Well he's finally done it. Brett Favre, who Sports Illustrated rightfully described as the wishiest washiest person in sport, has returned to the NFL and signed for the Minnesota Vikings - something that he was expected to do all summer until he announced he would not do so on July 28th. I have no problem with Favre coming back. One of the oldest sayings in sport is "you're a long time retired". Favre obviously still wants to play and he's found a team that will have him. I do however, have a huge problem with the Vikings and specifically Brad Childress for taking him on.

Let's look at the facts.

Favre is 40 in October and coming off surgery for a torn bicep in his throwing arm. How many 40 year olds have been successful quarterbacks in the league?

Last season his decline had begun before he injured his bicep. In September he three 12 touchdowns against 4 interceptions while completing 70% of his passes. From October on his record was 10 touchdowns and 18 interceptions. The nadir, of course, was December (2TDs. 8ints, no playoffs). The injury was not the only factor in Brett Favre's decline. If this was anyone other than Favre would those kind of numbers not be taken into account by a coach?

While getting surgery on his bicep, his surgeon - the renowned Dr. James Andrews spotted a partially torn rotator cuff. This injury nearly ended Chad Pannington's career. Twice.

When Favre announced back in July that he would not be coming back, he cited soreness in his knees and ankles and worried that his body would not last a whole season. In the space of three weeks what changed?

What kind of effect does this have on the quarterbacks the Vikings already have? Tavaris Jackson and Sage Rosenfels may not be long term prospects but having watched their coach chase the man from Hattiesburg all summer like a crazed lover what must they and the rest of the team think? The headcoach has basically turned around to them and said I have no confidence in you to lead this team to the playoffs. What if Favre's body does give out like he feared? Are they going to have the confidence or desire to step in and do a job for the team?

Madness. Absolute madness.